If the Caps by chance encountered them a genie who offered them a guarantee that they could replicate their on-ice product from Monday night, but the result would remain obscured, would they take it? You could probably bet on it. Too bad. The Caps didn’t come remotely close to capturing the dominance they saw in Game 3, and lost in overtime after playing far below their capabilities for most of the night.
Here is our breakdown of Game 1, Game 2, and Game 3.
Now let’s take a look at what worked and what didn’t in Game 4.
What Worked
Beagle scores! #CapsPens with 15:30 left in the 1st pic.twitter.com/AZeRLGC60v
— CAPITALS HILL (@CapitalsHill) May 5, 2016
We’re going to go with one “what worked” tonight (and limit ourselves in “what didn’t,” though we could go on and on). There are no silver-lining in this situation, and not a lot to take solace in, unless you consider the volume of 3-1 series leads Caps fans have seen dissolve. The Caps needed to be better tonight. They weren’t.
What Didn’t
Puck luck #CapsPens 1-0 pic.twitter.com/02sl3qMexg
— CAPITALS HILL (@CapitalsHill) May 5, 2016
Malkin finished regulation at a break-even possession count, but he was tied at this point for the Penguins team lead in individual scoring chances with there, which Patric Hornqvist and Matt Cullen both equaled. The stats don’t really do the on-ice product justice in this instance. Rest assured, the Caps didn’t have an answer for Evgeni Malkin during this one.
Braden Holtby didn’t play a terrible game, and, as he always does, came up big in more than one occasion. But there are very few universes in which the best goaltender in the world (for that season-year, anyway) shouldn’t be able to keep a puck that trickles for a solid fifteen feet out of the net. Sure, traffic, mass chaos, whatever, obfuscate things somewhat, but strong ability to track a puck through traffic is obviously a prerequisite for goaltending.
The second Pens goal of the game, a semi-breakaway for Cullen right off a center-ice draw, is obviously the product of myriad failings by the guys in white on the ice, but being cleanly beat by a puck that never left the ice is not a Thing That Happens Often to the Holtbeast we’ve been watching all season long.
- Barry Trotz’s Decision To Play Mike Weber
This one’s bitter as hell.
#pens score in OT pic.twitter.com/r8cNs1DPBW
— CAPITALS HILL (@CapitalsHill) May 5, 2016