Marcus Johansson: Tip Your Waitress, Not Your Shot
The element of surprise - it's a strategic component that's been around forever, from Sun Tzu to Chemistry Cat. And over the course of the first half of this 2011-12 season, Marcus Johansson has given us the opportunity to see its effectiveness in action.
Early on, Johansson was tipping (think "telegraphing," not "deflecting") his shots quite a bit. Predictably, this has resulted in a lot of relatively easy saves for opposing netminders. But he's been making strides in that area, and the difference is clear. After the jump, we'll take a look at how Johansson was tipping his shots, and how he's adjusted over the course of the season.
First up is a clip from back on October 27 when the Caps visited the Edmonton Oilers. What we see is Johansson ending up with a clear chance on net, but he drops his left shoulder and ends up shooting the puck right into Nikolai Khabibulin (you can see it best in the replay at the very end of the clip):
By dropping his left shoulder Johansson signals two things: that he is about to shoot, and that he's likely shooting high. That's a huge advantage to a veteran goalie like Khabibulin (though I suspect even NHL rookies would be able to read that play). The result: what should have been a prime scoring opportunity is harmlessly defused by Khabibulin.
Now let's take a look at what Johansson has done since that play (and what he should try to do more often).
The very next game against the Vancouver Canucks, Johansson came streaking down the wing and had an open shot on Roberto Luongo:
Look at how level Johansson's shoulders stay. This makes the release quicker and better-disguised; it gives the goalie less time to anticipate and react to the shot.
Now let's take a look at Johansson's first goal in Monday night's loss to the Los Angeles Kings:
The only tell Johansson has in that shot is the raised skate, but that's often a decoy and doesn't give away as much as the dipped shoulder does. By the time his shoulders give away the shot he's already into the shot release and there isn't much the goalie is going to divine.
Guys like Joe Sakic and Brad Richards are famous for their quick releases, and their shots were effective in large part because it was impossible to see the shot coming. It's unrealistic to expect Johansson to be the kind of goal-scorer Joe Sakic was, but if he can continue to fire his shots off quickly, more accurately, and less predictably, we may soon come to expect him to chip in even more offense than we might have previously thought him capable of. Being respected as a scorer can also open up more passing lanes, increasing overall scoring potential, right Nick?
38 comments
|
18 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
In the Vancouver clip, it’s extra helpful that the guy streaking down the other wing is Ovechkin; with Johansson not tipping his shot, as it were, I bet just about everyone in the arena thought he was going to dish it off to #8.
Eat, drink, and be merry! And then drink some more.
Wow. Awesome work, Rob. This is something I might have to start looking for – I’m wondering if it would be noticeable in other Caps forwards.
Failure is always an option.
Yeah, if you watch there are always ways to tell. The dropped shoulder is an easy one but there are other ways as well. Despite how good his shot is Semin rarely settles for a quick release so you can usually see him shift his balance and pull the puck into position before he shoots.
Please, call me F&B.
With Semin, it’s about the tradeoffs between switching the angle, velocity, and fast release, no?
Given that 28 is a very accurate shooter in his career, I don’t know that I fault him for that decision. Not implying that you do, of course.
"Essentially, all models are wrong, but some are useful" George E.P. Box
I have $50 to Olie's autism charity or So Kids Can and a beer on the under for 50/57/107 as AO's final stat line for 2011-'12
And on Pekka Rinne's PK SV% dropping under .920 by the end of the '12 season
by Knee high to a duck on Jan 11, 2012 12:24 PM EST via iPhone app up reply actions
Yeah, I’m not faulting him. And there are definitely trade offs. I just think quicker is better than harder or more accurate the vast majority of the time. If NHL goalies have time to get set and/or prepare for a shot they are probably going to save it.
Please, call me F&B.
Semin’s accurate SP = missing the net instead of shooting into the goalie.
I agree, quicker is the best way to go, which is why it drives me crazy when, at times, certain guys (Semin) take that extra moment to go corner picking. Get a quick, heavy shot off and you don’t have to worry about aim.
It isn’t even anger-inducing. It does not seem to be worth that kind of emotional investment. It might not even be disappointing any more. It is expected.
-Peerless 5.6.2011
Johansson shot low on the ice into Khabi’s pads, not high. Also, what a great subtle little play by Semin.
Hopefully he’ll start taking some tips from Backis. The shoulder dip is also related to where he’s carrying the puck. If you carry the puck off to the side, the goalie is pretty much assured that you’re going to shoot. Dip that shoulder and start twisting your hips, and he’s 99.99% sure you’re gonna shoot. Unless you’re Alex Semin or Ilya Kovalchuk, an NHL goalie is going to stop you 95/100 if he already knows you’re going to shoot and can see the shot.
Unleash the Apathy.
Although the counter to carrying the puck at the side is that if you carry it in front of you then you can’t shoot and you have to move the puck into shooting position, which is a tip in itself. I’d rather a player carry the puck in shooting position for the most part, but obviously you have to move it around and change it up as the situation dictates.
Please, call me F&B.
The reference to Backis is a nod to how he carries the puck more like Forsberg – feet spread wide for balance and puck protection, with the puck centered in front of his body. It’s hard to get good oomph on a shot from that position, but it also doesn’t allow the goalie to get set because you can pass, deke or shoot from that position. When MoJo carries the puck out wide to the side, he leaves himself open for lift checks and his passing options are usually limited to drop passes.
MoJo is definitely tipping less than last year. The picture at the top of this post typified how he approached every scoring chance last year. Puck to the side, shoulder dropped. . . one Mississippi. . . then shot.
Unleash the Apathy.
Shooting Coaches
Do teams ever have special coaches/assistants to work with players individually like hitting coaches in baseball?
"Just the fact that I knew something was bad, I knew it was probably broken, I knew I'd have to miss some time--that makes me upset more than anything."
by QuintinLainged on Jan 11, 2012 10:18 AM EST via Android app reply actions
I believe every team has “projects” during the season. Improving a young center’s face-offs is a good example. Likewise, I’d imagine that they work with certain players on particular weaknesses. But I’d doubt that they bring in outsiders for that, it’s likely the assistant coaches or other, more experienced players.
Unleash the Apathy.
Excellent points
Very well explained/illustrated. Thanks for the great content.
"The main ingredient of stardom is the rest of the team." - John Wooden
Disappointed that Rob vetoed my suggestion to title this post “Marcus Johansson Plays ‘Just The Tip’.”
Japers' Rink: Hockey blogging from the most powerful city in the world
by J.P. on Jan 11, 2012 11:15 AM EST reply actions 5 recs
Commenting just so F&B doesn’t get butthurt…
Release the Mackan!
by Killer_Carlson on Jan 11, 2012 1:22 PM EST reply actions 6 recs
But good stuff. I clearly have nothing to add.
Release the Mackan!
by Killer_Carlson on Jan 11, 2012 1:25 PM EST up reply actions
If you had to pick a Cap with the least legible release, who you got? I’m especially interested in hearing from the goalies on this one – seems like something y’all would look for.
"Essentially, all models are wrong, but some are useful" George E.P. Box
I have $50 to Olie's autism charity or So Kids Can and a beer on the under for 50/57/107 as AO's final stat line for 2011-'12
And on Pekka Rinne's PK SV% dropping under .920 by the end of the '12 season
by Knee high to a duck on Jan 11, 2012 2:10 PM EST via iPhone app reply actions
Green snapped his wrist? Shit…
Tu ne cede malis
by _Skullduggery_ on Jan 11, 2012 2:44 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Awesome post. Always great to have some extra content to sift through before a nervewracking game. Thanks.
by SFJerome on Jan 11, 2012 3:06 PM EST via iPhone app reply actions
Rob – Any tips on how this can be translated to the beer league players here? At my level, most players take roughly 7 minutes to wind up a wrist shot.

by 




































