Bruce Boudreau Rates Alexander Semin's Game
Sovetsky Sport has been running a series of articles called "Letters to the National Team", in which they ask various in-the-know folks to rate players for potential inclusion on Russia's 2010 Olympic hockey team. In todays edition, Dmitry Chesnokov and Pavel Lysenkov asked Bruce Boudreau to rate Alexander Semin in several different categories.
Letters to the National Team
28 February 2009
Pavel Lysenkov
Sovetsky Sport is finishing up its "Letters to the National Team" project, in which our correspondent is on a creative assignment for the coaching duo of Bykov/Zakharin, playing the part of scout and analyzing the game of NHL player candidates for the Russian national team. At last, we shall judge Washington forward Alexander Semin.
"So who's going to evaluate Sasha Semin?" asked his comrade in Washington after we had completed the "Letters to the National Team" on Fedorov and Kozlov.
We were thinking of asking Bruce Boudreau said Dmitry Chesnokov, our Correspondent in the nation's capital.
"Oh no, anybody but Bruce! He won't rate Semin very high.."
Nonetheless, we went to Boudreau, who had been named NHL coach of the year last season.
...And just to remind you, we compile our answers using a questionnaire which rates each category on a ten-point scale.
1. Passion (7)
"Semin has really improved his output," says Boudreau. "When I first came to Washington, I noticed that Alexander wasn't always engaged in the game. But now it has turned around. Semin enthusiastically fights for the puck a lot. I like the passion with which he competes."
2. Mobility (10)
"I don't think there is anyone that can move better than him. Whenever Semin has the puck, you get the feeling that he's got it tied on a string. He works it with really high speed. That is why Alexander averages more than one point per game.
"And you have to consider that he doesn't always play every shift with Ovechkin. He doesn't get 23 minutes per game, but only 19. Ovechkin will play on the PP for the entire two minutes, because he assumes the position of a defender. Semin only comes out on one special team, sometimes getting only one minute. But he can accomplish so much!"
3. Tactics (8.5)
"He is a talented guy, and he is able to guess the movement of his partners. Previously, the main problem for Semin was his English. Alexander reads the game better than 95 percent of the players on earth! But because he didn't speak English well, he didn't have a full rapport with his partners.
"Now, Semin is much more attack oriented. But at the same time he has started playing better in defense. He has a +27 rating. We rarely lose when he is on the ice. True, Alex sometimes takes a chance when he goes on the attack, but that is typical for a fast-attack forward."
4. Puck screening (8)
"Last year I wouldn't say to you what I'm saying now. But if, for example, we were leading by one goal in the last five minutes of the game, I would have Semin playing the entire time. When he has to play well in defense, he is one of the best. But if we are up 4:1, then Alexander might take a chance and make a turnover at center. Overall I like how he plays defense."
5. Aggressiveness (8)
"Semin is not a power forward. He is not like Ovechkin who will make 14 hits in a game. But Alex is so skilled with his stick that he doesn't lose battles for the puck. He is aggressive and fights to the end, especially in the last few minutes of the game."
6. Special Teams (7/10 = 8.5 average)
"Last season, Semin didn't play on the PK. But I noticed that he did that in the World Championship, and did it very well. So this season I used some of that Team Russia experience.
"It is only recently, when I put Semin on Ovechkin's line, that I stopped using them when we were a man down, because it was their line that came out on the ice immediately after the PK ended. Let him show himself more on the attack. If, however, we have some players injured or scratched, I can easily use Semin on the PK.
"Alexander is one of our leaders on the PP. That is why Washington is in third place in PP in the league, and first place if you count since November. This season Semin has already made 20 points (3+17) on the PP. That is an outstanding statistic."
7. Character (8)
"Semin has a talent for getting stupid penalties. But when the game is hanging by a thread, he can make the important goal. Just a few weeks ago we were playing against Boston, and the score was 1:1. Alexander snatched the puck, charged up the flank, made a powerful shot and brought us victory. And he does that quite often.
"He is a quiet guy. You don't hear Semin like you hear the industrial Ovechkin. But Semin is a fighter, always thirsting for the win. He just doesn't talk about it. I still remember the final in Quebec, when Semin made two goals. No, everything is in order with his character."
Would you choose Semin to go to the Olympics in Vancouver?
"He should automatically be selected, the same as Ovechkin."
What does Semin still need to work on?
"Nobody is perfect. Speaking about nuances, I wish that Alex would shoot a little bit lower. Semin is great in the attack, but his shots often go over the net. He always wants to put it in the corner of the net. He needs to work on his precision. There's no reason that Alex couldn't have had 30 goals by now. He has the hardest wrist shot! And if Semin corrects his aim, his productivity will sharply increase."
TOTAL: 58 (8.29 average)
Other ratings:
| Alexander Ovechkin |
Washington | 67.5 (9.64) |
| Pavel Datsyuk | Detroit | 67 (9.57) |
| Alexander Semin | Washington | 58 (8.29) |
| Alexander Frolov | Los Angeles | 57 (8.14) |
| Alexei Kovalev | Montreal | 52 (7.43) |
| Anton Volchenkov | Ottawa | 49 (7) |
| Viktor Kozlov | Washington | 45 (6.43) |
| Sergei Fedorov | Washington | 43 (6.14) |
20 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Semin is quite likely the most underrated player in NHL. True, he takes some stupid penalties but so does most of the players. And I think in last Worlds he was definitely one of the best players in team Russia
Как же так может быть?
The leader in goals per 60 minutes for players with more than 20 games played being called “underrated?” That’s sad if true.
I think it is true, though. How many Caps fans do you think would be surprised by that stat? And how many fans of other teams? I bet both would be very high percentages (though higher in the latter case).
I think Tim Thomas knows how good he is! Funny that this talks about his tendency to shoot high, given Thomas’ bizarre comment on the GWG rising.
But when the game is hanging by a thread, he can make the important goal. Just a few weeks ago we were playing against Boston, and the score was 1:1. Alexander snatched the puck, charged up the flank, made a powerful shot and brought us victory. And he does that quite often.
Today, for example.
Japers' Rink: Hockey blogging from the most powerful city in the world
“Nobody is perfect. Speaking about nuances, I wish that Alex would shoot a little bit lower. Semin is great in the attack, but his shots often go over the net. He always wants to put it in the corner of the net. He needs to work on his precision. There’s no reason that Alex couldn’t have had 30 goals by now. He has the hardest wrist shot! And if Semin corrects his aim, his productivity will sharply increase.”
we did see a few examples of this today. will be fun to see if he makes a concerted effort the rest of the season to keep shots on goal. is there a ratio stat for “shots on goal” vs. “shots not on goal?”
Interesting question. Here’s the answer:
Of all the Caps with more than 65 shots on goal, Semin has the worst shots-on-goal-to-missed-shot ratio (sorry for the formatting):
Player S/M
Matt Bradley 4.39
Michael Nylander 3.83
Brooks Laich 3.62
Sergei Fedorov 3.35
Eric Fehr 3.27
David Steckel 3.25
Viktor Kozlov 3.17
Mike Green 2.57
Nicklas Backstrom 2.57
Tomas Fleischmann 2.55
Alexander Ovechkin 2.53
Alexander Semin 2.10
Note that the bottom five guys here are also the team’s top five goal scorers.
Japers' Rink: Hockey blogging from the most powerful city in the world
by J.P. on Feb 28, 2009 5:42 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
I always felt that was the nature of the beast. If you shoot to score you are generally attempting harder shots to make assuming the goalie is doing his job. The whole point of playing goalie is to use angles to limit the area of available space to shoot. So the players that are scoring generally are attempting to hit the harder shots. Nothing more unsatisfying than a shot going directly into the stomach of the goalie.
Dumb question, does that include blocked shots?
Can't we get Chris Bourque a red jersey now? Thanks.
Nope. Missed shots are separated out from attempted/blocked shots.
Japers' Rink: Hockey blogging from the most powerful city in the world
bruce’s comments on semin’s defense in tight games (vs. 4-1 games) rings true. for those of us that thought “focus” was the most important area of improvement, semin could be the prime example.
that said, semin’s play down the stretch last season and into the world championships has me psyched about his future with the caps. if we cut semin loose in the offseason or in his contract season, as DMG suggested, i don’t think we have anyone currently on the roster that can replace his scoring. maybe this is more a reflection of my feelings on fehr/fleishmann, but if semin is a monster this postseason (and i’m betting he will be) it will be very difficult to let him go…no matter the salary cap implications or the package we get in return.
i think he could be the anti-kozlov in terms of playoff performance…although obviously one series is too small a sample.
And it cannot be said often enough, but on the day after tomorrow, Semin will turn 25. We’ve all lived with Semin’s drama since before the lockout, and some have wondered if he will ever grow up, but he’s still very young. If he turns 28 and still has “focus” problems, then maybe we can say it’s endemic and not something that maturity can solve…
by Gould Old Days on Mar 1, 2009 9:33 AM EST up reply actions
Semin -- Much Improved
I have noticed the great improvement in Semin’s game this year. A Plus-Minus rating that is almost unreal, given that he missed a number of games. Scoring average that is over one point per game.
And, to all those fans who rail on about Semin’s inconsistency. In the 44 games or so that he’s played, he has scored at one goal or gotten at least one assist in every game he’s played, except for 8 games. (And in one of those 8 games where he got neither a goal or assist, he was a shootout hero). So, in general, we can count on Semin to account for at least point a game. Pretty good consistency, huh! I’ll take that kind of inconsistency where he’ll get a point of some sort in over 80% of the games he’s played. (This, considering there are plenty of players who’s points per game is less than .80.)
When Green was in his scoring streak, guess who usually contributed an assist. Yes, that’s right, Alexander V. Semin.
Okay, he has taken some stupid penalties, but there are several other players on the Caps who do so also. (I won’t mention any names.) If Boudreau benched every Caps player who took a stupid penalty, they wouldn’t have enough guys to dress for the game.
It’s amazing how many fans still want to trade him or what ever.
I’ll give him credit for being emotionally resiliant. He may make a mistake but will come back with renewed determination and do something good to make up for it. It takes a certain amount of emotional resiliancy to bounce back.
Watching Semin develop (along with Ovechkin, Fehr and Fleischman, for that matter) is like watching my elder daughter grow up and come of age. (She’s nearly the same age as him — only a year younger.)
Good for Semin to see him improve by leaps and bounds and actually take to the coaching. It didn’t always seem like he responded very favourably to tough love in past years, and it was really hurting him. Maybe it’s maturity, maybe it’s Fedorov’s presence, maybe it’s something different altogether, but Semin has quietly gone about his way and provided that necessary balance to Ovie’s brash, in your face type game.
And good for Boudreau to take an active part in pushing him to be a better player, rather than accept Semin’s headstrong reluctance to open himself to him and the coaching staff.
Supporter of the Sergei Berezin "Give and Go" - You give me puck, then you go to hell
Thanks as usual Tuvan
This is yet another great translation Tuvan…..and of course keep it up!
by Puddin_an_Semin on Mar 1, 2009 12:36 PM EST reply actions









































